Commend! Don't Condemn
By
J.L.
Gupta
We live
in a world that has crucified Christ, assassinated Abraham Lincoln and murdered
Mahatma Gandhi. It is a ruthless, unkind and an ungrateful world. What are we
doing to improve it? Nothing?
Especially
these days when Campaign for Elections – 2014 is in full swing, it is obvious
that we censor, complain and criticise.
We decry, detract and disparage. We hunt for blemishes. We look for
faults. Like microscope experts, we magnify every mistake. We examine
everything with an innate desire to pass a sentence. We do not utilise the
critical faculty to correct errors but to pull down others. These traits are
becoming obvious during the past few days.
The largest democracy in the
world is going to elections. It is a big event. Everybody is watching us. And
what are we showing them? That we are a nation of faultfinders. Making baseless
complaints and circulating misleading information to incite religious
sentiment. We have religious riots. We have diversity. But no unity. All
parties are finding fault with the others. Using bad language. Calling the
other “Maut ka saudagar.” (Dealer in death.) ‘ISI Agent.’ And so on.
We seem to forget that the most censorious is
generally the least meritorious. Detraction is basically an evidence of
deficiency. It primarily indicates weakness as well as meanness. A detractor
may sometimes succeed and harm others. He can never elevate himself. One who
decries and disparages others shall always remain depressed himself.
Praise
may deceive, criticism can correct and reprimand can reform yet we paint
everyone black with one brush. We cannot say that all the big guns in the
country have a very small caliber. We cannot invade, needle and threaten
everyone. We cannot continue to reciprocate hospitality by hostility and
convert opportunities into difficulties. We just cannot continue deprecating
and destroying.
Facing calumny and criticism is the tax that
a man pays for his eminence. The celebrities cannot escape censor. In every age
and at all places in the world, men of eminence and virtue have passed through
a fiery persecution. But the hottest furnace produces the brightest steel.
Persecution only purifies. It brings the best out of a man.
To
continue doing one's duty is the best answer to calumny. No one can control the
evil tongue. But we can close our ears against a person who opens his mouth
against us. Let not envy fill our minds with evil. Let not malice make us mute.
Just don't chase the lie. It would 'automatically die.
Praise is to a person what
sunshine is to a sunflower. Praise is the wage for virtue. It helps a person to
endure many a peril and overcome many a grief. It is a debt that a man owes to
the virtues of another. It is a duty that must be performed with scrupulous
justice.
In today's materialistic world,
many know how to flatter. They even stoop to concur. However, not many know how
to praise. Veneration to human worth undoubtedly belongs to only a few. But let
us remember that he who has merit never envies others. The jealous man only
poisons his own food and spoils his own system. Envy is like a fly. It does not
get near anything which is clean. It only “rests upon the "sores".
Virtue shall always triumph
over vice. He who applauds must be appreciated. Just as flowers bestow
fragrance upon the air, life of a good man sheds light on the paths of others.
It remains a monument of human virtue. It extends its influence from generation
to generation.
Let us not tell the world that
we are a nation of the corrupt, dishonest and inefficient only. Let them know
that this nation of more than a billion is a ‘member of the select nuclear
club, its satellites are circling the outer space’ because the people are
capable and competent. Let us consecrate our energies to the creation of what
is good. Let us bury the bad and praise the good. Let us commend. Not condemn. All
Parties and Leaders. It shall be good for India and the Indians. Everywhere.
I am in complete agreement with the writer. He espouses a very noble aspiration. The political parties seem to have forgotten that their role and goal is to lead the country forward TOGETHER, work for the betterment of the country together, and with the Opposition acting as watchdog over the Ruling Party's actions. However, Constructive Criticism is a concept alien to them. And in election season mindless rhetoric has reached fever pitch with sometimes no holds barred, undignified contests that shame us. I wish for politicians to take a page out of the writer's book and aspire to something higher than themselves.
ReplyDeleteWe as a society are increasingly focussed on the negative .. If we want to move from one political party to another ... OUR usual comment would be "" this party is useless , corrupt, incompetent so now we want to try another ( in other words one more corrupt incompetent useless leader "" ... AND unfortunately thats all we get .
ReplyDeleteIf we focus on the positives and say " that leader did this and that good stuff and this new leader seems competent to do good in these other areas .. so let's elect him so that it shall benefit us. Each party and leader has some good and as citizens we need to focus on those issues and make a wise choice AS to what is the country needs at this juncture.
I relate to this issue all the time when my student in Golf comes to me and asks , Amandeep when I hit this vicious slice " what am I doing wrong ?? and my answer always is ... Let me give you a fix and once I have done that ONLY FOCUS on what you have to do to eradicate the slice and NEVER on why are you slicing . SMALL difference but makes a HUGE change !
Sir, got such a vibe of positive energy after reading your article. Otherwise these days social media like in facebook is just a place for mudslinging at each other.
ReplyDeleteSir, a very well articulated piece. Sometimes prejudice against our fellow humans knows no bounds - greed for power clouds our thoughts. Our politicos live up to the adage of power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely.
ReplyDeleteAbounding corruption in boundless territories. That seems to be the order of the day. However we have the great constitutional corrective in the hands of the people. The RIGHT to vote to be excercised with the RIGHT mind and spirit. With circumspection and deliberation. So let us ensure that our politicians are forced to keep the promises that they make.
ReplyDeleteI have only visited one time, but I can state clearly that India is a great country... it has great people... Time and task have taken me in different directions, however I remember my visit with much appreciation, good memories, and ongoing connections.
ReplyDeleteThat little guy on our shoulder telling us to blame and criticize... "the devil made me do it", although nowadays it's usually "STRESS made me do it". The other day I learned (via a TED talk) that stress is actually good for you... it's your body giving you the clues and help to deal with the situation. It seems that your body is also creating and releasing into your system agents that encourage social interaction, which I understand multiply as you take and search out positive interaction with others. In the simplest form, a scolded child looking for a hug from mom...
From a different perspective, "social media" seems to be the technical tool to connect e.g. as in recent events involving large groups of individuals in political unstable situations. Governments have tried to block these connections, in other cases "foreign governments" have moved to make these tools available in manipulative ways, and we see individuals grasping for their 15 minutes of agenda driven social media sunshine... it doesn't always work as it could and of course we get stuck with the advertising ;-).
It's good that events such as elections bringing stress and concern... it's also very obvious that the complainer doesn't get the point ;-)... Have I mentioned that our time is too important to be wasted listening to people who don't get the point.
another enjoyable post... thanks.
The content and the title phrase of this article is a potent philosophical lesson in itself- it works on many levels- not only for our country and its democratic mechanisms but also for its people as a mindful tool in the art of day to day living.
ReplyDeleteIn this day and age of perceived short term gains and increasing focus on the apparent rather than the real, rising above form and focussing on substance is imperative!
The writer offers a gentle but timely reminder of this fact - Cheers to him and all that which makes our country great!
I guess it is a human nature to complain. The psychology for complaining is that it gives the complainer an immense pleasure and satisfaction doing it and also it is quite easy. Poor people complain of not having enough money and rich for not having more money. A bachelor complains of inability in finding a suitable partner and the married man complains wishing he was human being again. Nobody seems to be ever content with their life and what they possess. Everybody is looking for a free lunch without working for it. Complaining also fulfills and strengthens the complainer’s ego and it veers him away from his responsibilities.
ReplyDeleteRemember the story of the fox who tried everything to get the grapes and in the end gave up saying that grapes were sour. Instead of admiring himself for the multiple efforts made to get the grapes, the fox complained. Likewise when people cannot achieve their desired goals, they grudge, grouch, complain and criticize others, God, the system, the society, and the government and pretty much everything else.
Forgive me Uncleji, you must have felt good in criticizing the Congress Party in your February 9 blog “Dame Democracy”. I give below a little snippet of your blog:
“In our country, the good cannot normally fight an election. More than that, it happens very often that the vanquished, if blessed by a member of the dynasty, is made the winner. The ministerial berth is given to the person who had lost at the hustings. The disapproved are brought in via the back door. Through the States they may not have ever represented. The peoples’ mandate is made meaningless.
At election times, slogans like “Garibi Hatao are raised. False promises of ‘Roti, Kapda aur Makaan’ are made. None have ever been fulfilled. Failure is the only thing, the Congress party has been a success at.”
And now evangelising to the contrary in “Commend! Don’t condemn”:
“Let us not tell the world that we are a nation of the corrupt, dishonest and inefficient only. Let them know that this nation of more than a billion is a ‘member of the select nuclear club, its satellites are circling the outer space’ because the people are capable and competent. Let us consecrate our energies to the creation of what is good. Let us bury the bad and praise the good. Let us commend. Not condemn. All Parties and Leaders. It shall be good for India and the Indians. Everywhere.”
I would agree with your above sermon whole heartedly.
Jai Hind from Odisha.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with the spirit of your thoughts. We must not give an impression to the world that we are a nation of the corrupt and inefficient. However, at the same time, those who were elected to represent us must be told that despite their bluster, we know they have been corrupt and inefficient for the last 10 years. How can we surrender our right to criticize those who have sold our country for their own personal gains. Should we watch silently while the government gives us no governance? Your criticism of the Congress has been accurate. It is the Congress supporters who can't tolerate any negative expression about the last 10 years. So much can be said about the way this party has let down this country. AAP I fear is no different. Because their cadre is mostly Congress supporters who can't openly support the Congress in view of the misdeeds of the last 10 years. So they now support AAP. Keep writing. Your thoughts shall stand vindicated on May 16th!
ReplyDeleteVery well written. The title itself says it all. It is true that it is easier to find faults with others and it is usually a cover up for one's own weaknesses. When we cannot elevate ourselves, we try to pull down others in the hope that we will somehow look better in the process. In the electoral process also its a shame that there is so much mud slinging at opponents rather than focus on what one has to offer to the country. This attitude is also reflective of the parliamentary process which has degenerated into merely blocking proceeds and yelling at each other. We hope that our country elects sensible and dedicated members to the Parliament this time who are focussed only on the positive.
ReplyDelete