DEATH SENTENCE
By
J.L. Gupta
What is the most
difficult thing that can confront a man? To sit in judgment over another human
being. To determine whether the person is guilty or innocent. To decide whether
the man should live or die. To Pronounce, "You are awarded - death sentence."
Man is not an uncivilized
brute. Nor a mere animal. He is civilized and sensitive. Some may feel sick at
the sight of an abattoir. Many may not be able to stomach the sight of an
animal being slaughtered. And life is God’s gift. No man should have the right
to take it away from another human being.
Yet, the world is not a
convent. It is not inhabited by nuns. Nor is it a monastery managed by monks.
It has its share of deviants. Children, men and women who do not value life.
They wield weapons. Would stab another for the smallest thing. Kill for a few
coins. They take away the life of another person to satisfy their own ego. We
cannot visualize all that one human being can do to another. Let me illustrate.
A man and his brothers
owned a piece of land. Adjoining that of their uncle and cousins. He started
installing a tube well. Just next to his uncle's. His cousin requested him to
shift the site so that both could get adequate supply of water. He did not
agree. The cousin went to the Court. He got an injunction. Even that was
violated. The cousin sought police help to ensure compliance with the court’s
directive. He got it. The police intervened.
It took steps to ensure compliance with the Court’s Order.
In the evening the man
picked up his gun. He let loose all hell on his uncle’s family. He killed his
uncle, two cousins and their wives. One of the ladies was eight months
pregnant. The sight of close relations bleeding to death did not even bother
him. He had just walked away. Six precious lives were taken away in less than
six minutes. Three generations were obliterated without a thought. In anger. In
a moment of madness. To avenge an imaginary insult. To be one up on the other members
of the family. Just to be able to install the tubewell at the place of his
choice. He was not bothered as to whether or not they would get sufficient
quantity of water.
Then, followed the
arrest. Interrogation. Investigation. Commitment. And the trial. The process of
law is really trying and tiring. Finally, the trial concluded. The Court
recommended the award of death sentence to the accused. The case was placed
before a Bench of two Judges of the High Court. The entire evidence was
examined. Re-examined. The Counsel did the hair-splitting. Then came the
moment. A trial for the two judges. Should the death penalty be confirmed? The
accused is young. In all probability, he would have a young wife. Small
children too. Aged parents as well. What would they do? How would they live?
The Judges imagined and examined everything.
All in all, it appeared
to be a traumatic experience. And then, with a grim and solemn look, one of
'the Judges wrote - "Death sentence is confirmed." Both signed it.
Just a sentence? Or, is
it a Just sentence? Should a man and a monster be treated alike? It never ceases
to trouble me.